In this case, Mother appealed a joint custody order because the trial court had previously found Father committed domestic violence against a different partner within the last five years. The trial court did not think it had to apply the Family Code section 3044 presumption against Father in the custody proceeding with Mother because it had found Father rebutted the presumption in the custody proceeding between Father and the different partner, involving a different child. The Court of Appeal reversed.
The Court explained that the legal rule of issue preclusion (also called collateral estoppel) did not apply because Mother and Father’s custody proceeding had different people and interests compared to Father’s custody proceeding with the different partner. If the 3044 presumption applies against a parent, it applies in every custody proceeding with that parent until and unless it is rebutted in each proceeding. Rebuttal as to one child with one parent is not the same issue as rebuttal as to another child with another parent. In essence, the presumption is unique to each child the abusive parent seeks custody of, and unique to each other parent the abusive parent litigates custody against. Finally, the Court also explained that the trial court’s failure to apply the presumption was prejudicial error because the court did not make the requisite findings under subdivision (f) of Family Code section 3044, and the court mistakenly relied in part on the preference for frequent and continuing contact found in sections 3020 and 3040.
This case also discusses issues related to appealability, sealing court records, the disentitlement doctrine, forfeiture, prejudice, and judicial bias.
